Super Mario Bros. 2 ($5,000)
Super Mario Bros. 2 is another game that is worth a small fortune. Super Mario Bros. 2 was first released in 1984 on the Nintendo Entertainment System. At the time the game cartridge only cost around $40 but today the value has increased tremendously. Now, a brand new Super Mario Bros. 2 game is worth around $5,000.
Not many people were willing to not open a copy of Super Mario Bros. 2 but there were a few that knew that this game would be worth something one day. The value of the game drops significantly if it isn’t brand new. Super Mario Bros. 2 was one of the most purchased games in the world during its peak.