American Girl Molly McIntire ($5,000)
American Girl dolls were another extremely popular doll brand that first came out in 1996. Like many dolls, American Girl dolls were highly collectible as they were crafted well and came in many different variants. One doll that stands out among the others as being the most valued is the Molly McIntire doll.
This doll was special as it was a representation of a little girl from the World War II era. When the doll was first released, Molly only cost around $85 and now she is valued at around $5,000. There are other American Girl dolls that are also worth a pretty penny so if you have any in good condition, take a look and see what they cost today.