You Probably Have These 15 Misconceptions About the Amish

Chris Hondros/Getty

The Amish, a Protestant denomination known for their simple lifestyle and close-knit communities, have captured interest for centuries. Their dedication to tradition starkly contrasts the fast-paced world around them. But how much do we really know about them? Beneath the stereotypes lies a complex and fascinating culture. Watch us dispel 15 common misconceptions about the Amish.

All Amish Live in Buggies

William Thomas Cain/Getty

While horse-drawn carriages are a familiar sight in Amish communities, they’re not the only mode of transport. Some communities allow bicycles and even limited car use for specific purposes, such as emergencies or commuting to work outside the community.

Amish People Reject All Technology

Scott Olson/Getty

The Amish approach technology cautiously, focusing on what aligns with their values. Many of them utilize electricity for lights and power tools in workshops but avoid technology that disrupts their focus on family and community.

Amish Women Are Oppressed

Chris Hondros/Getty

Amish women hold respected roles within the community. They manage households, raise children, and contribute significantly to the family’s livelihood through crafts and agriculture. While their roles may differ from mainstream society, they hold power in their communities.

The Amish Never Leave Their Communities

Adam Gray/Getty

During Rumspringa, a period between adolescence and adulthood, Amish youth are encouraged to explore beyond their world. This allows them to make informed decisions about joining the church as adults.

All Amish Dress Alike

Mark Wilson/Getty

The code varies among Amish subgroups. While plain dress reflects humility and simplicity, men and women within each group differ in color, style, and head coverings.

The Amish Don’t Pay Taxes

Chalirmpoj Pimpisarn/Getty

The Amish generally pay property and sales taxes. However, they may seek exemptions from Social Security and Medicare due to their reliance on community support systems for healthcare and financial aid in times of need.

The Amish Don’t Believe in Education

William Thomas Cain/Getty

Children in this community receive primary education, typically up to 8th grade. The curriculum focuses on practical skills for their way of life. Higher education is uncommon, but vocational training is encouraged.

The Amish Are Anti-Government

William Thomas Cain/Getty

The Amish usually avoid conflict with the government. They practice pacifism and often seek exemptions from military service due to their religious beliefs, preferring to contribute to society in other ways.

The Amish Are a Dying Religion

Mario Tama/Getty

Despite facing challenges, including technology and assimilation, the Amish population is growing. Their high birth rates and strong community bonds contribute to this. Some Amish groups are more open to modern conveniences than others, allowing for some adaptation while maintaining their core values.

The Amish Are All the Same

Mark Wilson/Getty

There are diverse Amish subgroups with varying degrees of strictness regarding tech, traditions, and dress code. The Old Order Amish are the most well-known, but other groups, like the New Order Amish, take a different approach.

The Amish Don’t Have a Sense of Humor

William Thomas Cain/Getty

Their humor may be subtle and focused on everyday life, but it’s a very present aspect of their culture. They enjoy practical jokes, riddles, and funny stories passed down through generations.

The Amish Are Inbred

William Thomas Cain/Getty

Amish societies are not isolated and interact with outsiders. They actively encourage marriage outside of close relatives. While some genetic conditions may be more prevalent due to the religion’s historical roots, the Amish actively try to reduce risks in future generations.

The Amish Live in Constant Harmony


Like any community, the Amish face internal conflicts. However, they have solid mechanisms for resolving issues, often relying on respected elders within the community to mediate and reach a solution.

The Amish Are Unprepared for Medical Emergencies


While they may avoid some modern medical practices, the Amish do not reject all medical care. They often use traditional remedies for minor ailments and seek external help in serious situations.

The Amish Are a Tourist Attraction


In several Amish communities, established businesses like furniture shops or bakeries welcome visitors. However, most prefer a life of privacy. When visiting an Amish country, it’s important to be respectful of their boundaries.


Leave a Reply