Bruno P
Historical films are known for hooking viewers to TV screens because they bring past eras and significant figures to life. However, in crafting engaging storylines, these films often sacrifice historical accuracy through certain omissions or misleading events that turn fact into fiction. While this approach makes for a great cinematic experience, it can also mislead audiences about what really happened. So, here are some of the most wildly inaccurate historical films of all time.
The Birth of a Nation (1915)
The Clansman, as originally called, is an American silent epic film notorious for its problematic portrayal of the Reconstruction era in the United States. It glorifies the Ku Klux Klan and presents a highly biased and inaccurate version of post-Civil War history. This film will forever remain controversial for its interpretation of American history, but we can not take away the fact that it’s a landmark film in the history of the US.
Amadeus (1984)
While this movie is based on the rivalry between composers Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and Antonio Salieri, the film exaggerates their antagonism and portrays Salieri as being overly jealous and directly responsible for Mozart’s death. Allegedly, it was reported that Mozart died from the parasitic disease known as trichinosis, contrary to the film showing Salieri as the one who poisoned Mozart to death.
JFK (1991)
To be fair to Oliver Stone, it’s nearly impossible to portray the life and death of President John F. Kennedy in a movie that is only a few hours long. This film presents a highly speculative and controversial account of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, heavily implying a conspiracy without solid historical evidence. Due to this, many historians have criticized the film for its narrative inaccuracies.
Braveheart (1995)
A true historical epic drama that presents William Wallace as a kilt-wearing Scottish freedom fighter in the late 13th century. In reality, kilts weren’t worn in Scotland until the 16th century. Additionally, Wallace’s relationship with Princess Isabella is entirely fictional, as she was a child during the events of the film. Despite the inaccuracy of its historical events, Braveheart is easily one of the greatest films ever made.
Titanic (1997)
Every man and his dog has probably watched Titanic. While the film was praised for its visual effects and excellent performances by Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet, there are concerns about the events’ accuracy. The portrayal of some historical figures, like First Officer William Murdoch, is controversial, with Murdoch shown as taking a bribe and committing suicide, which can’t be confirmed. Also, the central love story between Jack and Rose is entirely fictional.
Shakespeare in Love (1998)
One of the greatest love stories ever told is a fictionalized account of William Shakespeare’s life. While this romantic comedy is entertaining, the narrative is entirely speculative and not based on historical facts. A leading character was portrayed as Earl of Wessex—a title that had not existed for over 500 years in Shakespeare’s time. Also, it was recorded that Queen Elizabeth I never entered a public theater like she did in the film.
Elizabeth (1998)
According to audience reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, if Queen Elizabeth I comes back to watch, she won’t even recognize herself in this wildly inaccurate version of events. It portrays the life of Queen Elizabeth I in a different way, particularly in her relationship with Robert Dudley. Also, it incorrectly portrays her transformation into the “Virgin Queen” as a deliberate choice rather than a complex political evolution.
The Patriot (2000)
Remember the character Benjamin Martin—a peaceful farmer driven to lead the Colonial Militia—in a film telling the story of the American Revolution war. Several historical figures were merged into this character while distorting the intricacies of the American Revolution. A notable inaccuracy can be seen in a scene that shows British soldiers burning a church full of civilians, an event that never happened.
Gladiator (2000)
Inspired by the 1958 novel—Those About To Die—this screenplay was loosely based on real events that happened within the Roman Empire. While Emperor Commodus did fight in the arena, he was not killed by a gladiator but was instead assassinated by his political rivals. The portrayal of Commodus’ rule is also exaggerated. So, according to Ridley Scott, some historical facts were too “unbelievable” to be included.
A Beautiful Mind (2001)
Truly, one of the most inaccurate historical films in the 2000s is A Beautiful Mind. This theatrical trailer film portrayed contrary views of the life of mathematician John Nash, particularly in its depiction of his mental illness and his relationships. The portrayal of his delusions and recovery is simplified and dramatized to look good on screen.
The Last Samurai (2003)
Directed by Edward Zwick, this American action drama film suggests that a single American could have significantly influenced the last stand of the samurai. In reality, the conflict between the samurai and the Japanese government was far more complex and involved no American intervention.
Troy (2004)
This film, based on Homer’s “Iliad,”—portrays the legendary Trojan War—but it alters many aspects of the story, including the portrayal of Achilles and the duration of the Trojan War. A notable inaccuracy can be seen in how a war that unfolds over a decade is compressed into a few weeks of conflict in the movie.
300 (2006)
When thinking of a film that rips historical records to shreds, 300 comes to mind. It significantly exaggerates the Battle of Thermopylae, depicting the Persians as monstrous and the Spartans as superhuman warriors. The title of this historical action film is based on a comical view because the real battle involved more than just 300 Spartans, including thousands of other Greek allies.
The Other Boleyn Girl (2008)
This historical romantic drama distorts the relationship between Anne and Mary Boleyn by presenting Mary Boleyn as Anne’s younger sister despite Mary being older. Furthermore, some crucial historical details, like Anne’s motivations and her interactions with Henry VIII, are altered for narrative tension.
The Imitation Game (2014)
According to Information Is Beautiful—a visual blog—the film was just 42.3% accurate compared to real-life events. It is famous for exaggerating Alan Turing’s role in cracking the Enigma code while oversimplifying the efforts of the entire team at Bletchley Park. In addition, it fictionalizes Turing’s relationship with Joan Clarke and his interactions with British authorities.
Comments
Loading…