15 Thought-Provoking Questions Atheists Often Ask The Religious

Viktor Aheiev/Getty

In philosophical and theological discourse, the dialogue between atheists and religious adherents is fascinating and occasionally heated. Atheists challenge the foundations of faith, divine reality, and religious doctrine on human life. These questions serve as reflection and discussion points for individuals of all belief systems. Let’s discuss 15 questions atheists commonly ask the devout.

What kind of proof would convince you that a god or gods exist?


The question seeks an understanding of the criteria by which a religious person would accept the existence of a deity. Atheists ask this to know whether religious ideas stand on empirical evidence or other forms of reasoning.

How are you sure your particular God (s) are the true ones?


Here, the focus is on religious certainty. They’re asking believers to explain why they are confident that their specific religious beliefs are correct among the multitude of faiths and gods worshipped throughout history.

If God is all-loving, why is there suffering in the world?


The problem of evil births a classic question that confronts the concept of a benevolent, all-powerful God. Atheists pose this question to understand how believers reconcile the presence of suffering with the idea of a loving deity.

How does free will exist if God knows everything that will happen?


This question relates to the theological notion of predestination and challenges how real free will is in the presence of an omniscient God who knows the future.

Is morality from God or created by humans?

Parradee Kietsirikul/Getty

Morality is subjective, and some religious people fuse expected religious behavior and morality, hence the question. It inquires about the source of moral values, asking whether they are derived from divine commands or are human constructs.

How do you interpret seemingly contradictory passages in religious texts?

Sergio Yoneda/Getty

It’s no news that different parts of some religious books contradict each other. It can be conflicting moral teachings or differing accounts of historical events. Since these books are held in high esteem and are sometimes even unquestionable, it makes sense to want to know how believers reconcile apparent inconsistencies within them.

How do your religious beliefs inform your views on modern science and ethics?


Atheists ask this to know how religious beliefs influence a person’s stance on scientific theories (e.g., evolution) and contemporary issues (e.g., LGBTQ+ rights).

Why are there so many different religions if there’s one true God?

Thai Noipho/Getty

This question confronts the idea of religious pluralism and asks believers to provide insights into why there are numerous conflicting religions if only one true God exists.

Can you explain the concept of an all-powerful, all-knowing being existing outside space and time?


Here, the intention is to understand the nature of the divine, mainly how a being can be omnipotent, omniscient, and transcend physical limitations.

How does God interact with the physical world, if at all?


Atheists ask this question to address the notion of divine intervention. They want to see what believers will say about God’s influence in the world.

Why create humans who will reject God and end up in hell?


This question challenges the notion of divine benevolence. It asks believers to make clear the purpose behind creating beings destined for eternal punishment.

Why is faith required without sufficient evidence of God’s existence?

shuang Paul wang/Getty

The atheist struggles to understand why belief in God often requires a leap of faith rather than being based on empirical evidence. This question addresses the role of faith in religious belief.

Why do good things happen to bad people and vice versa if God is just?


Atheists sometimes ponder the concept of divine justice, so with questions like this, they demand believers to explain how they reconcile the apparent lack of correlation between moral behavior and life circumstances.

Why send people to hell for eternity, especially if they’ve never heard of God?


Challenging the fairness of eternal punishment, especially for those who may not have had the opportunity to learn about or accept a particular religious belief, this question seeks an explanation of why a just God will do that.

How are you sure religious experiences aren’t just psychological?


Here, the nature of religious experiences is questioned as believers are asked to consider whether such experiences could be solely attributed to psychological or natural causes.


Leave a Reply