10 Best Peanut Butters Brands Ranked

brown powder in brown round container

Credit: Unsplash

The 10 best peanut butter brands are hard to choose, especially if one doesn’t like peanut butter. But from the spread, the texture, and, of course, the taste, it’s not hard for some to figure it out.

clear glass jar with brown liquid

Credit: Unsplash

Fix and Fogg

It doesn’t sound like a peanut butter brand, does it? Considering that it’s a high-end peanut butter though makes it easier to understand. The super crunchy is hard to spread, but thankfully it’s easy to eat on its own.

peanut butter with black spoon

Credit: Unsplash

Peanut Butter & Co.

It’s interesting to see a no-frills name and package, but some people get worried when they see this. Thankfully, this brand has a great white chocolate flavor that sneaks its way from the jar to your tongue.

photography of brown nuts

Credit: Unsplash


Do you remember those pleasing elementary school lunches? This texture will bring you back in the most pleasant of ways.

four jars of peanut butter sitting on a table

Credit: Unsplash

Santa Cruz

So, dark and light peanut butter? It works well with a premium coffee, and somehow it works just as well here. Peanut butter should taste nutty, right?

peanut butter jar on cutting board

Credit: Unsplash

Nuts ‘n More

There’s a little more nutrition to this brand and that’s great. But it still tastes great and hits the tongue like the sweet and pleasing goodness you’d expect.

pile of peanuts

Credit: Unsplash


It’s a brand that a lot of people don’t know much about. But this tastes like a beefed-up version of something you’d buy in bulk, only better.

brown powder in clear glass jar

Credit: Unsplash

Stonewall Kitchen

There aren’t a lot of different flavors like other brands when talking about Stonewall. But it does focus on creamy and chunky, and that’s all a person needs.

a sandwich with peanut butter and jelly on it

Credit: Unsplash


For health nuts, this is one of those that strikes the palette just right. There are cheaper brands, but they don’t deliver the same quality with a simple and very clean approach.

a bowl filled with a mixture of brown batter

Credit: Unsplash

Once Again Organic

Some people like Once Again, others won’t eat it more than once, ironically. But the sunflower seed-based butter is unique, that’s for sure.

peanuts in clear plastic pack

Credit: Unsplash

Big Spoon Roasters

Just the name should get a person excited, unless they think it’s a jar of coffee, of course. But as number one on this list, it had some stiff competition. At the end of the day, however, the different flavors and robust flavors helped it reach the top.


Leave a Reply