These 11 Things From the ’90s Are Worth a Small Fortune—and You Might Own One

The 1990s were a time of innovation, cultural shifts, and iconic trends that left a lasting impact on generations. From toys to technology, many items from this vibrant decade have gained significant value over time. Nostalgia plays a powerful role, as collectors and enthusiasts are willing to pay a premium for pieces that evoke memories of their youth. Whether tucked away in attics or proudly displayed, these items are not just relics of the past but potential treasures of the present. Explore this list of 11 things from the ’90s that could be worth a small fortune today.

Pokémon Cards (Especially 1st Edition Holographics)

Pokémon cards, especially the first edition holographics, have become iconic symbols of 90s gaming culture. A 1st Edition Charizard Holo card is particularly coveted, fetching prices upwards of $200,000 at auctions. These cards are not just pieces of cardboard but intricate artworks that capture the imagination.

Collectors treasure them for their design and rarity, making them highly sought after. Even lesser-known holographics hold significant value, often selling for hundreds or thousands.

The thrill of collecting these cards lies in the hunt for rare editions, each telling a story of its own. For some, it’s about reliving childhood dreams in a tangible way.

Vintage Nintendo Games & Consoles

The world of video games was forever changed by classics like ‘The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.’ Sealed copies of such games, along with consoles like the SNES or Nintendo 64, are a collector’s dream. Imagine finding a mint-condition console; it’s like unearthing a piece of gaming history.

These items don’t just offer entertainment; they represent a golden age of gaming. Prices for these treasures can soar over $10,000, reflecting their status in the gaming community.

Collectors are drawn to the nostalgia and artistry, preserving the memories of endless gaming sessions and iconic adventures.

Tamagotchis (1st Gen or Japan-Only Editions)

Tamagotchis, the digital pets of the 90s, were more than just toys—they were companions. Those who owned the original 1996 models, especially in rare colors or Japanese-only editions, hold a piece of digital pet history.

Their value has skyrocketed, with some selling for $300–$2,000 depending on condition. Tamagotchis were revolutionary, teaching responsibility through playful interactions.

Collectors cherish these items, not just for their monetary worth, but for the joy and memories they evoke. Owning a first-gen Tamagotchi is like keeping a little piece of the 90s alive in your pocket.

Polly Pocket Playsets (Pre-1998)

Polly Pocket playsets were tiny worlds that sparked the imagination of many children in the 90s. The original micro-sized sets, crafted with intricate details, are now highly valued among collectors.

Pre-1998 editions, especially rare ones, can fetch anywhere from $500 to over $1,000 for full collections. These miniature playsets offered a universe of creativity, where every detail was a delight.

Collecting Polly Pockets is about more than just nostalgia; it’s about celebrating the artistry and craftsmanship that brought these tiny worlds to life. Each set is a treasure trove of memories and miniature magic.

Beanie Babies (with Tag Errors or Rare Editions)

In the 90s, Beanie Babies were more than just stuffed toys—they were a craze. The value of these plush collectibles often lies in their rarity, with specific editions like the Princess Diana Bear or Peanut the Elephant in royal blue fetching between $5,000 and $25,000.

Tag errors can also add significant value, turning an ordinary Beanie Baby into a prized possession. These items became cultural icons, representing the height of 90s toy trends.

Collectors are captivated by their charm and the stories they carry. Each Beanie Baby is a piece of history, encapsulating the fervor of its time.

First-Edition Harry Potter Books

The magic of Harry Potter began with the first-edition books, sparking a literary phenomenon. A 1997 first-print ‘Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone’ (British edition) is a true collector’s gem, often selling for $50,000 or more.

The allure of these books extends beyond their pages, as they symbolize the beginning of a beloved series. A signed copy by J.K. Rowling elevates its value even further.

For collectors, owning a first-edition Harry Potter book is akin to holding a piece of literary magic, a testament to the impact of Harry’s story on readers worldwide.

Vintage Lisa Frank Stationery & Backpacks

Lisa Frank’s stationery and backpacks were the epitome of 90s color and creativity. Known for their vibrant designs, these items have become sought-after collectibles.

Sealed sticker packs, Trapper Keepers, and specific notebooks from the 90s can sell for $100 to $500 or more. They capture the playful spirit and bold aesthetics that defined an era.

Collectors are drawn to Lisa Frank’s work for its nostalgic charm and artistic flair. Each item is a visual feast, a reminder of a time when school supplies were as colorful as our imaginations.

McDonald’s Happy Meal Toys (Disney, Beanie Babies, or Pokémon Sets)

The joy of opening a McDonald’s Happy Meal in the 90s often came with the thrill of discovering a new toy. Full sets, particularly those unopened and in original packaging, have become valuable collectibles.

Promotions featuring Disney, Beanie Babies, or Pokémon are especially prized, sometimes reaching values in the hundreds or thousands. These toys are a nostalgic reminder of childhood excitement and the appeal of collectible series.

Collectors appreciate these items not just for their monetary value, but for their nostalgic significance. Each toy is a small piece of the past, cherished by those who remember the joy they brought.

Game Boy (Especially the Game Boy Color & Game Boy Advance SP)

Gaming in the 90s was defined by the portability and fun of the Game Boy. Particularly, the Game Boy Color and Game Boy Advance SP have become iconic collectibles.

Unopened or mint-condition models can now sell for $800 to $2,000 or more, especially when paired with rare game bundles. These handheld consoles were a gateway to a world of gaming adventure.

Collectors value these Game Boys for their nostalgic significance and their role in gaming history. Each console represents a moment in time, a piece of the legacy of portable gaming that captivated a generation.

MTV’s “Beavis and Butt-Head” or “Daria” Merch

The irreverence and humor of ‘Beavis and Butt-Head’ and ‘Daria’ made them cultural icons of the 90s. Merchandise from these MTV shows, like original shirts and VHS tapes, holds special value among collectors.

Promo items or limited-run figurines are particularly prized, often fetching hundreds or more. These items symbolize a unique slice of 90s pop culture that resonates with fans to this day.

Collectors are drawn to this merch for its humor and nostalgia, representing an era where edgy, animated commentary made waves. Each piece is a tribute to the show’s impact and enduring legacy.

VHS Tapes (Disney Black Diamond Editions & Horror Films)

VHS tapes may seem like relics of the past, but certain editions hold significant value. The ‘Black Diamond’ Disney collection, featuring classics like ‘Beauty and the Beast’ and ‘Aladdin,’ are particularly coveted.

Some rare horror films on VHS also attract high prices, though actual sale values can vary widely. These tapes are more than just movies; they’re memories of family movie nights and beloved stories.

Collectors prize these VHS tapes for their nostalgic appeal and rarity. Each cassette is a time capsule, capturing the magic of 90s cinema and the joy of rewinding to relive favorite scenes.