18 Forgotten ’90s Heartthrobs Who Look Completely Different Now

18 Forgotten ’90s Heartthrobs Who Look Completely Different Now

Luke Perry captured hearts as the brooding Dylan McKay on ‘Beverly Hills, 90210.’ His rebellious charm and deep voice made him a fan favorite. As years went by, Perry transitioned from teen idol to a respected actor, embracing roles that showcased his versatility. Unfortunately, he passed away in 2019, but his legacy endures. Perry’s later years saw him with distinguished salt-and-pepper hair and a gentle, warm persona. Did you know? He was also a devoted father and a passionate advocate for environmental causes. His spirit lives on through his memorable performances and enduring impact.

1. Jonathan Taylor Thomas (JTT)

Jonathan Taylor Thomas, or JTT as he was fondly known, was the quintessential ’90s teen idol. With his cherubic face and endearing smile, he captured hearts on ‘Home Improvement.’ Yet, as adulthood beckoned, JTT chose a path less traveled, stepping away from Hollywood’s relentless glare.

Today, at 42, he lives a life of relative anonymity, far removed from the chaos of showbiz. Swapping scripts for a more serene existence, JTT’s transformation is profound. Gone are the boyish charm and youthful exuberance; in their place, a wiser, more introspective individual emerges.

His journey from stardom to seclusion is a testament to his desire for a quieter, more grounded life.

2. Devon Sawa

Remember the wide-eyed wonder of Devon Sawa in ‘Casper’? That youthful innocence has evolved into a more rugged, mature persona. Transitioning from mainstream hits like ‘Final Destination’ to indie films, Sawa has embraced diverse roles that challenge his acting chops.

At 45, his appearance is a testament to his journey, reflecting both growth and resilience. The once-boyish charm has given way to a more seasoned look, complete with a stubble that hints at experience.

Sawa’s career path showcases an actor unafraid to take risks, exploring realms outside the conventional Hollywood narrative. His transformation is as much personal as it is professional, marking a new chapter in his life.

3. Andrew Keegan

Andrew Keegan, remembered for his charismatic role in ’10 Things I Hate About You,’ has undergone a spiritual transformation. Swapping Hollywood glamour for holistic harmony, he’s now at the forefront of a spiritual and wellness community.

At 44, Keegan’s life is a tapestry of mindfulness, far removed from his heartthrob days. His look is more grounded, exuding peace and serenity rather than the youthful exuberance of yesteryears.

His journey emphasizes a shift from external validation to inner fulfillment, focusing on community building and spiritual growth. It’s a refreshing evolution, highlighting a man who has found purpose and tranquility beyond the silver screen.

4. Jason Priestley

Once the golden boy of ‘Beverly Hills, 90210,’ Jason Priestley has seamlessly transitioned from in front of the camera to behind it. His iconic teen idol looks have matured into a distinguished, salt-and-pepper appearance.

At 54, Priestley has carved a niche in the film industry as a director, showcasing talents that extend beyond acting. His evolution is marked by a deep understanding of storytelling from both sides of the lens.

This transition reflects his enduring passion for the craft of filmmaking, proving that his contributions to Hollywood are far from over. Priestley’s journey from starry-eyed actor to respected director is inspiring.

5. Rider Strong

Rider Strong, who captured hearts as Shawn Hunter in ‘Boy Meets World,’ has transformed from teen heartthrob to a thoughtful creator. Now a writer, director, and podcaster, Strong embraces a bohemian and intellectual style.

At 44, his look is a blend of casual and cultured, exuding curiosity and creativity. His post-acting career is rich with storytelling, allowing him to explore narratives from new perspectives.

Strong’s transformation showcases his passion for the arts beyond acting, illustrating a journey full of introspection and innovation. His story is one of embracing change and finding new avenues for expression and influence.

6. Mark-Paul Gosselaar

Mark-Paul Gosselaar will forever be Zack Morris to many, yet his journey beyond ‘Saved by the Bell’ is both dynamic and intriguing. Today, as a father and seasoned actor, he sports distinguished gray hair that complements his mature roles.

At 49, Gosselaar’s evolution from teen icon to respected television actor is impressive. He’s taken on challenging roles in TV dramas, showcasing a range that extends far beyond comedic antics.

His varied career path highlights a commitment to growth, both personally and professionally. Gosselaar’s ability to reinvent himself while maintaining a connection to his roots is admirable, ensuring his legacy endures.

7. Matthew Lawrence

From ‘Mrs. Doubtfire’ to popular teen sitcoms, Matthew Lawrence’s charm was undeniable. However, his journey has taken a new direction, one filled with camaraderie and creativity.

At 43, Lawrence is more rugged and engaged with the world of podcasting, collaborating with his brothers, Joey and Andy. This venture reflects his desire for meaningful conversation and connection.

His transformation is about embracing authenticity and pursuing passions beyond acting. Lawrence’s evolution from a famous child actor to a thoughtful adult is a testament to his adaptability and drive to explore new horizons in entertainment.

8. Scott Wolf

Scott Wolf, once the boyish sweetheart of ‘Party of Five,’ has gracefully transitioned into roles that epitomize a dad-next-door vibe. His youthful looks have matured, carrying an air of wisdom and relatability.

At 55, Wolf continues to act, embodying characters that resonate with audiences seeking authenticity and warmth. His presence on screen remains engaging, reflecting a seasoned actor comfortable in his own skin.

Wolf’s transformation is a celebration of life’s chapters, from teen idol to respected actor, capturing the essence of growth and evolution both personally and professionally. His journey reassures fans that change can bring new, rewarding experiences.

9. Freddie Prinze Jr.

Freddie Prinze Jr., known for his rom-com charm in ‘She’s All That’ and ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer,’ now savors a quieter life, focusing on family and culinary pursuits.

At 47, Prinze Jr. has shifted from the limelight to the kitchen, penning cookbooks and relishing in domestic bliss. His transformation is one of finding joy and fulfillment in everyday moments.

This transition captures a man comfortable with his journey, embracing life’s simple pleasures. Prinze Jr.’s evolution from Hollywood heartthrob to content family man is a heartwarming tale of personal happiness and growth.

10. Shane West

Shane West, the brooding star of ‘A Walk to Remember,’ has embraced a scruffier style as he delves into darker TV roles. His on-screen presence continues to captivate, now with an added layer of depth and intensity.

At 45, West’s transformation is marked by versatility and a willingness to explore diverse characters. His look reflects the depth of experience gained over years in the industry.

This evolution speaks to an actor unafraid of reinvention, constantly seeking new challenges. West’s journey from romantic lead to multifaceted performer is a testament to his enduring passion for storytelling.

11. Joshua Jackson

Joshua Jackson, fondly remembered as Pacey from ‘Dawson’s Creek,’ has seamlessly transitioned into the realm of prestige dramas. His career reflects an actor who has matured both in craft and presence.

At 45, Jackson exudes the confidence and gravitas that come with years of honing his skills. His roles today are rich and varied, often demanding a depth that showcases his evolution.

Jackson’s journey is one of growth and exploration, proving that his talents extend far beyond teenage antics. His continued success and adaptability in Hollywood highlight a career that’s both enduring and evolving.

12. James Van Der Beek

James Van Der Beek, eternally associated with Dawson from ‘Dawson’s Creek,’ has embraced a life filled with humor and family.

At 46, his role as a father to six children adds a delightful layer of depth to his public persona. His foray into self-aware comedy reveals an actor comfortable with self-reflection and reinvention.

Van Der Beek’s transformation is a refreshing blend of nostalgia and modernity, showcasing a man who relishes life’s unpredictable journey. His story is one of embracing change with an open heart and a willingness to adapt to new personal and professional landscapes.

13. Chris O’Donnell

Chris O’Donnell, once the pretty boy of ‘Batman & Robin,’ has navigated the transition to seasoned actor with grace. His steady role on ‘NCIS: LA’ showcases a matured presence that resonates with audiences.

At 53, O’Donnell’s appearance is a blend of experience and confidence, embodying characters that reflect his journey. He’s a testament to enduring talent and the ability to evolve with time.

O’Donnell’s career is marked by consistency and growth, illustrating a path that balances fame with personal fulfillment. His transformation from heartthrob to respected actor is one of dedication and resilience.

14. Ethan Embry

Ethan Embry, from ‘Empire Records’ to ‘Can’t Hardly Wait,’ has embraced a transformation that’s both striking and genuine. His clean-cut look has given way to tattoos and a rugged vibe that mirrors his evolving career.

At 45, Embry’s appearance reflects a journey of authenticity, marked by roles that often challenge conventions. His transformation highlights an actor unafraid to express individuality and take on diverse characters.

Embry’s story is one of embracing change and exploring new artistic avenues, ensuring his presence in Hollywood remains dynamic and engaging. His journey is a celebration of personal and professional growth.

15. Paul Rudd

Paul Rudd is a unique case in Hollywood; from ‘Clueless’ to the Marvel Cinematic Universe, he seems to defy aging. His charm and charisma remain as potent as ever, captivating audiences across generations.

At 54, Rudd’s appearance is almost unchanged, a testament to his timeless appeal. His ability to play charming leads with ease is a rare gift in the industry.

His enduring success speaks to an actor who connects effortlessly with viewers, blending humor with sincerity. Rudd’s career is a remarkable journey of consistency, proving that some talents truly stand the test of time.

16. Dean Cain

Dean Cain, once Superman in ‘Lois & Clark,’ has transitioned into roles that reflect a different kind of heroism. His shift to commentary roles highlights a new chapter in his diverse career.

At 57, Cain’s appearance carries the gravitas of experience, a blend of age and wisdom that complements his current endeavors. His journey reflects adaptability and a willingness to embrace change.

Cain’s transformation from caped hero to insightful commentator showcases a career that’s both versatile and impactful. His story is one of evolution, capturing the essence of growth and the pursuit of meaningful work.

17. Mark Wahlberg

Mark Wahlberg, from ‘Marky Mark’ fame to Oscar-nominated actor, exemplifies a remarkable transformation. His career spans music, acting, and entrepreneurship, each phase marked by success and reinvention.

At 52, Wahlberg’s physical transformation into a fitness mogul is as impressive as his professional journey. His entrepreneurial ventures showcase a business acumen that complements his artistic achievements.

Wahlberg’s story is one of relentless ambition and adaptability, an inspiring tale of a man who evolved from a teen idol to a multifaceted powerhouse. His ability to grow and diversify is a testament to his enduring appeal and resilience.

18. David Boreanaz

David Boreanaz captured hearts as the brooding vampire in ‘Buffy/Angel,’ and his journey into military dramas and crime procedurals marks an impressive evolution.

At 54, Boreanaz’s look has matured, reflecting the depth of experience gained over his career. His roles today carry a gravitas that resonates with audiences seeking compelling storytelling.

Boreanaz’s transformation highlights an actor who continues to challenge himself, exploring complex characters with nuance and intensity. His journey from supernatural heartthrob to seasoned performer is a testament to his commitment to the craft.