15 Forgotten 2000s Stars Who Deserve a Comeback

15 Forgotten 2000s Stars Who Deserve a Comeback

Remember when flip phones were cool and reality TV was just getting started? The 2000s gave us some of the most memorable celebrities who ruled our screens, radios, and hearts. Many of these talented stars have stepped away from the spotlight, but their contributions to pop culture deserve recognition. Here are 15 incredible performers from that unforgettable decade who we’d love to see make a triumphant return.

1. Brendan Fraser

Action heroes don’t get much more likable than Brendan Fraser. During the early 2000s, he starred in blockbuster hits like The Mummy series, capturing audiences with his perfect blend of humor and adventure.

Fraser’s charm made him a household name, yet he quietly stepped back from Hollywood’s biggest stages. His acting range extended beyond action films into dramatic roles that showcased real depth.

Recently, fans have rallied behind him, celebrating his genuine personality and undeniable talent. A full comeback would remind everyone why he became such a beloved figure. His warmth and skill deserve another moment in the sun, proving that true talent never fades away completely.

2. Jennifer Love Hewitt

With a smile that could light up any screen, Jennifer Love Hewitt became a 2000s icon through shows like Ghost Whisperer and Party of Five. Her relatable characters made viewers feel connected to every story she told.

Beyond acting, she showcased musical talent and wrote books that resonated with young women everywhere. Her versatility set her apart from many of her peers during that era.

Though she’s taken on smaller projects recently, her fanbase remains loyal and hopeful. A major comeback role would showcase how her skills have only improved with time. Hollywood needs more performers who bring both heart and professionalism to every project they touch.

3. Hayden Christensen

Becoming Anakin Skywalker in the Star Wars prequels thrust Hayden Christensen into worldwide fame almost overnight. His portrayal of the conflicted Jedi showed emotional complexity that many young actors struggle to achieve.

After the trilogy ended, he stepped away from major Hollywood productions, choosing independent films instead. Critics initially divided over his performance have since recognized the difficulty of his role.

Star Wars fans have grown to appreciate his contribution to the beloved saga more each year. His return in recent Disney+ series proved he still has that magnetic screen presence. More leading roles would allow audiences to see his growth as a mature, seasoned performer.

4. Chad Michael Murray

Teen drama royalty reached its peak with Chad Michael Murray’s portrayal of Lucas Scott on One Tree Hill. His brooding good looks and sensitive character made him the ultimate 2000s heartthrob for millions of viewers.

Murray also starred in romantic comedies like A Cinderella Story, proving his range extended beyond television. His chemistry with co-stars created unforgettable on-screen moments that fans still discuss today.

While he’s continued acting in various projects, none have matched his earlier cultural impact. A comeback in a major film or prestige television series would reintroduce his talents to new audiences. His dedicated fanbase would absolutely celebrate seeing him reclaim his spot among Hollywood’s leading men.

5. Willa Ford

Pop music in 2001 got a fierce new voice when Willa Ford released her hit single I Wanna Be Bad. Her bold style and catchy hooks positioned her as a rising star in the competitive music industry.

Ford transitioned into acting with appearances on shows and reality television, showing she had more than one talent. Her confidence and stage presence made every performance memorable and entertaining.

Unfortunately, her music career didn’t sustain the initial momentum, and she eventually pursued other ventures. However, nostalgia for early 2000s pop has created the perfect environment for her return. A new album or collaboration would remind everyone of her undeniable star quality and infectious energy.

6. Jesse Metcalfe

Desperate Housewives introduced the world to Jesse Metcalfe as the handsome gardener who caused quite a scandal on Wisteria Lane. His character became an instant sensation, making him one of television’s most talked-about newcomers.

Metcalfe went on to star in John Tucker Must Die and the soap opera Passions, building a solid resume. His good looks combined with genuine acting ability created a formula for success.

Though he’s worked steadily in Hallmark movies and other projects, mainstream recognition has eluded him recently. A high-profile role in a streaming series or major film would showcase his matured talents. Fans remember his charisma and would love to see him return to the cultural conversation.

7. Jodi Lyn O’Keefe

Tall, striking, and incredibly talented, Jodi Lyn O’Keefe made her mark in films like She’s All That and Halloween H20. Her presence commanded attention whether she played the villain or a complex supporting character.

Television audiences recognized her from Prison Break and Nash Bridges, where she demonstrated range across different genres. Her modeling background gave her a natural confidence that translated beautifully to the screen.

Despite consistent work, she hasn’t landed the breakout role that matches her abilities and screen presence. A major comeback would finally give her the recognition she’s deserved for decades. Her combination of beauty, talent, and experience makes her perfect for today’s sophisticated television landscape.

8. Tara Reid

American Pie turned Tara Reid into a comedy icon virtually overnight during the late 90s and early 2000s. Her portrayal of Vicky brought warmth and humor to one of the decade’s most successful film franchises.

Reid continued with roles in Josie and the Pussycats and Van Wilder, building her comedic credentials. Her girl-next-door appeal made her relatable to audiences across the country.

Personal struggles and tabloid coverage overshadowed her professional accomplishments for many years. However, recent years have shown her resilience and determination to continue pursuing her passion. A well-chosen comeback role in a comedy series could remind everyone of the talent that made her famous initially.

9. Carmen Electra

Few names defined 2000s pop culture quite like Carmen Electra, who became synonymous with glamour and entertainment. Her work on Baywatch and in Scary Movie films made her a recognizable face worldwide.

Electra’s dancing, acting, and modeling created a multi-faceted career that many tried to emulate. She brought energy and confidence to every project, making even small roles memorable.

While she’s remained active in various entertainment ventures, mainstream visibility has decreased over time. A comeback in a major production would celebrate her enduring appeal and show business savvy. Her name still carries weight, and audiences would embrace seeing her back in the spotlight she once dominated so effortlessly.

10. Kelly Osbourne

Reality television found one of its most authentic voices when The Osbournes premiered, featuring Kelly Osbourne and her famous family. Her quick wit and rebellious spirit made her an instant fan favorite among viewers.

Kelly pursued music, releasing albums that showcased her rock influences and personal style. She later became a fashion commentator on shows like Fashion Police, proving her versatility.

Her honest discussions about personal struggles have made her an inspiration to many facing similar challenges. A comeback in television or music would highlight her growth and continued relevance. Her unique perspective and fearless personality deserve a platform that reaches today’s audiences who value authenticity above all else.

11. Mandy Moore

Candy made Mandy Moore a teen pop sensation in 1999, launching a music career that defined early 2000s radio. Her sweet voice and wholesome image appealed to families and young fans alike.

Moore transitioned brilliantly into acting with the tear-jerking romance A Walk to Remember, proving she had serious dramatic chops. Her voice work as Rapunzel in Tangled introduced her to an entirely new generation.

While This Is Us brought her back to prominence recently, her 2000s music deserves renewed appreciation. A tour celebrating that era or new music blending her pop roots with mature themes would thrill longtime fans. Her journey from teen star to respected actress shows remarkable growth worth celebrating.

12. Mischa Barton

The OC wouldn’t have been the cultural phenomenon it became without Mischa Barton’s portrayal of troubled teen Marissa Cooper. Her performance captured the complexity of adolescence with remarkable depth and sensitivity.

Barton’s fashion sense influenced an entire generation, making her a style icon beyond her acting work. She appeared in independent films that showcased her range beyond television drama.

Personal challenges and media scrutiny derailed what seemed like an unstoppable career trajectory. However, time has allowed for reflection and healing, making now perfect for a professional resurgence. A carefully selected role in a prestige drama could remind everyone of the raw talent that made her such a compelling performer originally.

13. Mýa

Smooth R&B vocals and incredible dance moves made Mýa one of the 2000s most talented performers. Her hit Case of the Ex dominated radio, while her collaboration on Lady Marmalade won a Grammy Award.

Mýa’s artistic vision extended beyond singing into acting and choreography, creating a well-rounded entertainment career. Her music videos were events that fans eagerly anticipated and discussed.

Though she’s continued releasing music independently, mainstream recognition has faded compared to her earlier success. A collaboration with today’s top producers or a major tour would reintroduce her incredible talents. Her voice remains as powerful as ever, and new audiences deserve to discover what longtime fans have always known about her brilliance.

14. JoJo

At just 13 years old, JoJo released Leave (Get Out) and stunned everyone with her powerhouse vocals. Her voice carried a maturity and strength that seemed impossible for someone so young to possess.

Record label disputes tragically stalled her career during what should have been her prime years. Despite these setbacks, she fought to reclaim her music and artistic freedom.

JoJo has released excellent albums since regaining control, but mainstream recognition hasn’t matched her talent level. A major promotional push or high-profile collaboration could finally give her the comeback she’s earned. Her story of perseverance combined with undeniable vocal ability makes her one of the most deserving artists for renewed success and widespread appreciation.

15. Michelle Williams

Destiny’s Child conquered the world, and Michelle Williams contributed her beautiful voice to that legendary trio’s success. Her gospel-influenced vocals added depth and soul to hits that defined an era.

After the group disbanded, Williams pursued a successful gospel music career, earning Grammy nominations and critical acclaim. Her authenticity and faith-based message resonated with audiences seeking meaningful music.

Though she’s remained active in theater and music, mainstream pop culture recognition has been limited. A crossover project blending her gospel roots with contemporary R&B could introduce her to wider audiences. Her talent deserves celebration beyond being remembered solely as a Destiny’s Child member, showcasing her individual artistry and remarkable vocal gifts.