Chloe Peterson
10 Underrated Prime Video Thriller Series You’ll Want to Binge
Streaming platforms overflow with content, making it easy to miss hidden gems buried beneath the blockbusters.
Prime Video hosts a treasure trove of thriller series that deserve far more attention than they receive.
If you crave suspense, psychological twists, and edge-of-your-seat storytelling, these underrated shows will keep you hooked from the first episode to the last.
1. Tell Me Your Secrets (2021)
Three damaged souls collide in this twisted psychological puzzle that refuses to reveal its hand too quickly.
A woman searching for her missing daughter, a former serial killer trying to start fresh, and a predator with his own agenda—their stories weave together in ways you won’t see coming.
The pacing feels deliberate, allowing tension to build naturally as past sins come crashing into the present.
Lily Rabe delivers a haunting performance as someone trapped between grief and obsession.
The show explores how trauma reshapes identity and whether redemption is ever truly possible.
Every character hides something, making trust impossible and keeping you second-guessing until the final moments.
2. Absentia (2017–2020)
Imagine vanishing for six years, then waking up with zero memory of where you’ve been or what happened.
FBI agent Emily Byrne faces this nightmare when she resurfaces, only to find her husband remarried and her son calling another woman mom.
Worse yet, she becomes the prime suspect in a series of murders that match her missing years.
Stana Katic brings fierce determination to a character fighting to reclaim her life while proving her innocence.
The mystery deepens with each season, exploring themes of identity, motherhood, and survival.
The show balances action-packed investigations with emotional family drama, creating a thriller that hits both your head and heart.
3. Breathe (2018–2023)
How far would you go to save your child?
This Indian thriller asks that question and pushes the answer into terrifying territory.
A father facing his son’s terminal illness makes choices that cross every moral line, setting off a cat-and-mouse game with a determined investigator.
The show doesn’t present easy villains or heroes—just desperate people making impossible decisions.
R. Madhavan’s performance captures the anguish of a parent willing to destroy lives to save one.
The second season shifts perspectives but maintains the same moral complexity and gripping suspense.
Cultural context adds layers to the storytelling, making familiar thriller tropes feel fresh and unpredictable throughout both seasons.
4. The Terminal List (2022– )
Chris Pratt trades his usual action-hero charm for something far darker in this military revenge saga.
Navy SEAL James Reece returns home after a disastrous mission that killed his entire platoon, only to discover his memory might be hiding deadly secrets.
As he digs deeper, a massive conspiracy emerges, forcing him to question everything he thought he knew about loyalty and duty.
The show doesn’t shy away from heavy themes like PTSD and survivor’s guilt, giving the story emotional weight.
Each episode peels back another layer of deception, keeping viewers guessing who to trust.
The action sequences hit hard, but the psychological unraveling of Reece makes this more than just another military thriller.
5. The Consultant (2023)
Corporate horror meets psychological thriller when a mysterious consultant takes over a gaming company after its CEO’s brutal murder.
Christoph Waltz plays Regus Patoff with unsettling calm, wielding fear like a scalpel to reshape the workplace into his twisted vision.
Employees find themselves trapped in a nightmare where refusing his bizarre demands carries consequences worse than losing their jobs.
The show taps into workplace anxiety in ways that feel disturbingly relevant.
Each episode introduces new horrors hiding behind professional facades and polite corporate speak.
Dark humor cuts through the tension, but the underlying dread never lets up, making this a unique blend of satire and genuine terror.
6. The Devil’s Hour (2022– )
Every night at exactly 3:33 a.m., Lucy Chambers wakes up screaming.
Her life feels fractured—her son shows no emotion, her marriage crumbles, and disturbing visions plague her waking hours.
When a detective investigating brutal murders crosses her path, connections emerge between her nightly terrors and the crimes, suggesting something far stranger than coincidence.
Peter Capaldi brings chilling intensity as a suspect who seems to know more about Lucy than she knows about herself.
The supernatural elements blend seamlessly with crime investigation, creating an atmosphere thick with dread.
The show rewards patient viewers, slowly revealing a mind-bending puzzle that connects past, present, and something beyond normal understanding.
7. Ballard (2025– )
Detective Renée Ballard works the night shift, handling cases other investigators have given up on.
Cold files pile up, filled with victims whose stories deserve endings, and Ballard refuses to let them fade into forgotten paperwork.
Her relentless pursuit of justice puts her at odds with a police system more interested in protecting its reputation than solving crimes.
The show captures the gritty reality of detective work without glamorizing the process.
Ballard’s character feels refreshingly real—flawed, stubborn, and driven by genuine compassion rather than glory.
Each investigation peels back layers of institutional corruption, showing how systems fail victims.
The tension comes not from explosive action but from watching someone fight an uphill battle against powerful forces.
8. Steal (2024)
A perfectly planned heist goes sideways in the opening minutes, setting off a chain reaction of betrayal and violence.
What starts as a straightforward theft unravels into something far more complex, with conspiracies stacked on top of conspiracies.
Trust becomes the rarest commodity as former allies turn on each other, and the real masterminds reveal themselves.
The fast pacing never lets up, throwing new complications at characters before they can catch their breath.
Each episode ends with revelations that flip the script on everything you thought you understood.
The show excels at keeping viewers off-balance, proving that in the world of high-stakes crime, nothing is ever what it seems at first glance.
9. Red Queen (2024– )
A brilliant investigator with an extraordinary IQ lives in self-imposed isolation, her genius both gift and curse.
When a serial killer starts leaving puzzles that only she can solve, authorities force her back into the field despite her psychological vulnerabilities.
The cat-and-mouse game becomes deeply personal as the killer seems to know exactly which buttons to push.
This Spanish thriller celebrates intelligence without making its protagonist superhuman.
Her abilities come with real costs, including social difficulties and overwhelming anxiety.
The cases themselves reward viewers who pay attention to details, offering fair-play mysteries where clues exist for those sharp enough to spot them.
The cultural setting adds distinctive flavor to familiar thriller territory.
10. Butterfly (2025)
Everyone believed Agent Rebecca Sato died during a mission gone wrong, but she survived and built a quiet life far from espionage.
That peace shatters when enemies from her past track her down, forcing her back into a world of international intrigue and deception.
The mission that supposedly killed her holds secrets that powerful people want buried, and Sato finds herself caught between governments with conflicting agendas.
The spy craft feels grounded rather than fantastical, focusing on manipulation and information warfare over gadgets.
Personal stakes elevate the action as Sato fights not just for survival but for the life she tried to build.
Emotional fallout from years of living double lives adds depth to the espionage thrills.
Comments
Loading…