Harper Hall
Shopping at Costco can be a treasure hunt for bargain-loving foodies. While the warehouse giant offers amazing deals on many items, not everything deserves a spot in your cart. Some prepared foods come with a convenience tax that might make your wallet wince, while others deliver incredible value that’ll make you feel like you’ve discovered a secret. Let’s explore which Costco meals are worth skipping and which ones deserve your hard-earned cash.
1. Rotisserie Chicken Salad
The ready-made rotisserie chicken salad seems like a smart buy until you check the price tag. At nearly double what you’d spend making it yourself, you’re paying a premium for someone else to shred that chicken and mix in a few veggies.
A whole Kirkland rotisserie chicken costs just $4.99, and basic salad ingredients are budget-friendly too. With minimal effort, you could prepare nearly twice the amount at home in under 15 minutes.
The taste isn’t anything special either – often over-dressed and under-seasoned. Save your dollars and create a fresher, more flavorful version tailored to your preferences.
2. Frozen Gourmet Pizzas
Those fancy frozen pizzas with artisanal toppings might catch your eye, but they’ll also catch your wallet off guard. Many cost $15-20 each, yet rarely deliver flavor that matches their premium price tag.
The crust often turns soggy or tough after baking, and those high-end toppings lose their distinct flavors in the freezing process. Store brands at regular grocery stores offer comparable quality at half the price.
If you’re craving pizza that’s truly special, you’d be better off adding a few gourmet toppings to a more affordable base or supporting your local pizzeria for truly exceptional flavor.
3. Pre-Made Sushi Platters
Sushi cravings can strike anytime, but Costco’s pre-made platters might not be the answer. While they look impressive, these trays typically cost $20-30 yet contain mostly simple rolls with minimal fish.
The rice often becomes dense and loses its proper texture sitting in refrigeration. Even moderate sushi enthusiasts will notice the quality difference compared to restaurant-made options.
Local sushi restaurants frequently offer lunch specials with fresher fish and better craftsmanship at similar price points. When you factor in quality and taste, the convenience factor doesn’t justify the markup you’re paying for these mass-produced rolls.
4. Ready-Made Sandwich Platters
Those colorful sandwich trays seem perfect for your next gathering until you do the math. For around $30-40, you’re getting basic sandwiches with minimal fillings that would cost about half to make yourself.
The bread often becomes slightly soggy by the time you serve them, and the meat and cheese portions are surprisingly skimpy. Many contain more bread than filling, leaving guests still hungry after snacking.
With just 20 minutes of prep time, you could create a more impressive spread with fresher ingredients and customized options for guests with dietary preferences. Your homemade version would taste better and stretch your dollars much further.
5. Bakery Cakes
Costco’s sheet cakes are legendary for their size, but not necessarily their value. At $20+ each, they seem reasonable until you consider the quality of ingredients and customization limitations.
The frosting tends to be overly sweet and made with shortening rather than butter, while the cake itself is mass-produced. Local bakeries might charge slightly more but offer better ingredients, more flavor options, and personalized decorations.
For special occasions, the generic appearance and one-size-fits-all approach of Costco cakes might leave you wishing you’d spent a few dollars more elsewhere. If you’re a decent baker, making your own would cost about half as much.
6. Organic Cold-Pressed Juices
Health-conscious shoppers might grab those colorful bottles of cold-pressed juice without noticing they’re paying nearly $8 per bottle! That’s a steep premium for something that contains maybe $2 worth of produce.
These juices do offer convenience and nutrition, but their short shelf life means you’re paying for something that must be consumed quickly. Many contain apple juice as a filler, diluting the benefits of the featured ingredients.
Investing in a decent juicer would pay for itself after just a dozen homemade batches. Alternatively, conventional grocery stores often sell similar products for 30-40% less during weekly sales.
7. Prepared Salads with Dressing
Those giant plastic containers of caesar, cobb, or garden salads seem convenient, but you’re paying nearly triple what the ingredients cost. A typical prepared salad runs $10-15 but contains maybe $4-5 worth of vegetables.
By the time you get them home, the greens have often started wilting from sitting in dressing. The vegetables lose crispness quickly, leaving you with a soggy disappointment by day two.
Bagged salad kits from Costco offer much better value, or simply buying the components separately. Pre-washing and chopping your greens on the weekend gives you fresher salads all week for a fraction of the cost.
8. High-End Cheese Platters
The beautifully arranged cheese boards at Costco make entertaining easy but come with a hefty markup. These platters typically cost $25-35 yet contain cheeses that would total about $15-20 if purchased separately.
The selections are often basic varieties rather than truly special artisanal options. Many include filler items like basic crackers or dried fruit that add little value but bulk up the presentation.
Creating your own cheese board lets you select exactly what your guests will enjoy. Costco’s individual cheese selection is actually excellent and reasonably priced – buying blocks and cutting them yourself saves significantly while allowing for more interesting and higher-quality options.
9. Kirkland Signature Rotisserie Chicken
At just $4.99, this juicy bird is perhaps the best deal in the entire warehouse. Each chicken weighs around three pounds and comes perfectly seasoned and ready to eat, no cooking required!
The quality consistently beats grocery store competitors that charge $7-9 for smaller birds. One chicken easily provides protein for multiple meals – from sandwiches to soups to salads.
Costco famously sells these as a loss leader, meaning they actually lose money on each chicken to get customers in the door. Take advantage of this strategy by making this versatile protein a regular part of your shopping list. It’s one of the few truly inflation-proof deals left in grocery shopping.
10. Hot Dog and Soda Combo
This iconic combo has maintained its $1.50 price tag since 1985, making it one of America’s best fast food deals. The quarter-pound all-beef hot dog comes on a freshly steamed bun with unlimited soda refills.
Former Costco CEO Jim Sinegal famously threatened his successor with bodily harm if the price ever increased. The quality surpasses most fast food competitors – the hot dogs are made without fillers or by-products and taste remarkably good.
While not the healthiest option, it’s an affordable treat that can save your shopping trip when hunger strikes. Many members admit to stopping by just for this meal deal even when they don’t need to shop!
11. Chicken Bake
For $3.99, this hearty creation delivers incredible value that many Costco shoppers overlook. The golden-brown crust encases chicken, bacon, caesar dressing, and cheese in a delicious handheld meal that could easily feed two people.
Each bake packs enough protein and calories to fuel you through a long afternoon. The flavors blend perfectly – savory chicken, smoky bacon, tangy dressing, and melty cheese create a crave-worthy combination.
Compared to fast food meals costing $10-12, this satisfying option saves significant money while tasting homemade rather than processed. It reheats surprisingly well if you can’t finish it in one sitting.
12. Pizza by the Slice
For just $1.99, Costco serves up a slice that’s closer to a quarter of a pizza than what most places call a slice. Each enormous portion weighs nearly a pound and covers an entire paper plate!
The crust achieves that perfect balance between chewy and crispy, while toppings are surprisingly generous. Pepperoni slices come loaded with more meat than many delivery chains provide on an entire pizza.
Feeding a family of four with Costco pizza slices costs under $8 – try matching that value anywhere else! While not gourmet, the quality consistently beats most national pizza chains charging three times as much per serving.
13. Acai Bowl
Costco’s acai bowl delivers exceptional value in the often overpriced world of health food. At around $5, it costs half what specialty shops charge for similar portions.
Each bowl comes loaded with antioxidant-rich acai blend topped with fresh berries, banana slices, and crunchy granola. The portion size is generous enough to serve as a complete meal rather than just a snack.
Finding healthy, ready-to-eat options at this price point is nearly impossible elsewhere. While smoothie shops might charge $9-12 for comparable bowls, Costco manages to offer this nutritious option without the typical ‘health food markup’ that makes clean eating expensive.
14. Kirkland Signature Burritos
Packed with hearty fillings like seasoned beef, beans, and cheese, they deliver bold flavor and satisfying portions that make mealtime effortless. Whether you’re feeding a hungry family or just need a quick lunch option, these burritos are a go-to favorite.
They heat up beautifully, taste deliciously homemade, and cost a fraction of what you’d pay for takeout. Budget-friendly, filling, and full of flavor—these burritos are proof that convenience and quality can absolutely go hand in hand.
15. Salad Kits
Costco’s refrigerated salad kits offer the perfect middle ground between convenience and value. Each package contains enough greens and toppings for 5-6 servings at around $5-7 total – that’s about $1 per generous portion!
Unlike fully prepared salads, these kits maintain freshness because the components remain separated until serving time. The ingredients are consistently high-quality, with crisp vegetables and flavorful dressings that rival restaurant offerings.
Adding a protein like rotisserie chicken creates complete meals for days. When restaurants charge $12-15 for similar salads, these kits demonstrate how smart shopping can maintain healthy eating habits without straining your budget.
16. Snack Packs
Those handy packages of hummus with veggies or cheese with crackers offer exceptional value compared to similar products elsewhere. Costco typically charges $8-10 for 6-8 individual packs – each substantial enough for a satisfying snack.
The quality consistently impresses, with fresh vegetables that maintain their crunch and creamy hummus that tastes homemade. The cheese varieties feature real dairy products rather than processed alternatives, while crackers stay perfectly crisp in their sealed compartments.
Similar convenience packs at airports or convenience stores often cost $5-7 each! Having these ready-to-grab options prevents expensive impulse purchases when hunger strikes away from home.
Comments
Loading…