13 Forgotten 2000s Shows That Deserve a Reboot

13 Forgotten 2000s Shows That Deserve a Reboot

The 2000s were a golden era for television, bringing forth a plethora of innovative and captivating shows. While some continue to enjoy a lasting legacy, others have faded into the shadows despite their exceptional storytelling and unique concepts. This list shines a light on 13 forgotten gems from the 2000s that, despite their brief runs, left a lasting impression on their fans. These shows stand out for their creativity, compelling characters, and memorable plots. They explore diverse genres, from whimsical dramedies to intense sci-fi mysteries, each deserving a second chance to captivate a new generation of viewers.

1. Pushing Daisies (2007–2009)

In a world where pies have magical powers, “Pushing Daisies” enchants with its colorful storytelling and unique premise. At the heart of this dramedy is Ned, a pie-maker with the extraordinary ability to bring the dead back to life. His power, however, comes with strings attached, leading to a series of whimsical yet dangerous escapades.

Narrated with charm, the show explores love, mystery, and moral dilemmas. It’s a tale where every pie is baked with a pinch of magic and a dollop of whimsy. Critics adored it, but despite its acclaim, it was canceled too soon.

Fans still yearn for its return, citing its innovative narrative and enchanting visual style.

2. Better Off Ted (2009–2010)

“Better Off Ted” takes a comedic dive into the absurd world of corporate America. At its core is the Veridian Dynamics corporation, where ethical boundaries are often blurred, and innovation knows no bounds. The protagonist, Ted Crisp, navigates the challenges of a satirical workplace, balancing sanity with the company’s outlandish demands.

Witty and sharp, the show offers a humorous critique of corporate culture. Each episode uncovers new absurdities, from cryogenics to weaponized pumpkins.

Despite its clever writing and engaging characters, it was ahead of its time, leading to an untimely cancellation. Yet, its fans still hope for a revival, longing for its return to the small screen.

3. Jericho (2006–2008)

Facing the aftermath of nuclear attacks, “Jericho” portrays a small town’s resilience and struggle for survival. The fictional town of Jericho becomes a microcosm of humanity, showcasing the strength and solidarity of its residents.

The tension is palpable as they grapple with dwindling resources, political intrigue, and the unknown fate of the outside world. Each episode delves deeper into the mysteries surrounding the attacks, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats.

Though it cultivated a dedicated cult following, its run was short-lived. Fans continue to rally for its return, eager to explore the untold stories of this post-apocalyptic drama.

4. The 4400 (2004–2007)

Unexplained disappearances meet unexpected returns in “The 4400,” a sci-fi mystery that keeps audiences guessing. Over decades, 4,400 people vanished without a trace, only to reappear suddenly, untouched by time. Each returnee harbors a unique ability, adding layers to the unfolding mystery.

The narrative weaves through themes of identity, power, and ethics, as society grapples with these evolved humans among them. The show’s strength lies in its rich character development and tight plotting.

Though its story remained incomplete, fans still celebrate its innovative approach to the sci-fi genre, hoping for a continuation of its intriguing tale.

5. Eli Stone (2008–2009)

Eli Stone, an ordinary lawyer, embarks on an extraordinary journey when he begins experiencing prophetic visions. These visions, often accompanied by musical numbers, guide him to cases that challenge both his legal acumen and moral compass.

The show’s charm lies in its blend of humor, drama, and fantasy, as Eli navigates the legal world with newfound purpose. Each episode sees him confronting societal issues, all while seeking deeper meaning in his personal life.

Though brief, its run left an enduring impression, with fans remembering its unique storytelling and thought-provoking themes. A reboot could offer fresh perspectives on its timeless questions.

6. Reaper (2007–2009)

“Reaper” combines humor and horror in a tale of an unlikely hero. Sam Oliver, a slacker, finds himself thrust into a supernatural world when he learns his parents sold his soul to the Devil. Tasked with capturing escaped souls, Sam’s life takes a turn for the bizarre.

While grappling with his destiny, he balances friendships, love, and the peculiar demands of his new role. The show thrives on its clever writing and endearing characters, offering laughs amid eerie escapades.

Despite its engaging premise, it ended too soon. Fans still hope for Sam’s return, eager for more of his devilish adventures.

7. Dead Like Me (2003–2004)

In “Dead Like Me,” death is only the beginning for Georgia “George” Lass. Unexpectedly reaped herself, she joins a group of grim reapers tasked with guiding souls to the afterlife. This dark comedy offers a unique perspective on life and death, blending existential musings with humor.

Each reaper, with their own quirks, provides a mix of camaraderie and conflict as they navigate their peculiar roles. George’s journey is both poignant and humorous, reflecting on life’s fleeting nature.

Though its questions remained unanswered, the show’s distinctive charm and thought-provoking themes continue to resonate. A reboot could delve deeper into its intriguing afterlife narrative.

8. Journeyman (2007)

In “Journeyman,” time becomes both ally and adversary for Dan Vasser, a reporter who inexplicably begins traveling through time. His journeys, unpredictable and uncontrollable, lead him to pivotal moments where he must alter destinies.

The show blends personal drama with historical intrigue, as Dan juggles his time-traveling life with family responsibilities. Each episode offers a fresh glimpse into different eras, exploring the ripple effects of his actions.

Though brief, its impact was lasting. Fans still dream of a comeback, eager to follow Dan’s unfinished journey through time and uncover the mysteries that bind past and present.

9. Wonderfalls (2004)

In the quirky world of “Wonderfalls,” Jaye Tyler’s life takes an unexpected twist when inanimate animal figurines start speaking to her. Their cryptic advice propels her into bizarre and often humorous situations, leading to unexpected personal growth.

Set against the backdrop of a Niagara Falls gift shop, the show explores themes of destiny, sanity, and self-discovery with a whimsical touch. Jaye’s reluctant adventures offer both laughs and insights into the human condition.

Despite its brief run, its cult status endures, with fans longing for a return to its unique blend of humor and heart. A reboot could offer new tales of Jaye’s surreal journey.

10. The Middleman (2008)

“The Middleman” plunges into the world of comic-book-style heroism with Wendy Watson, a young artist turned crime-fighter. Recruited by a secret agency, she battles bizarre villains alongside her mentor, the Middleman.

The show’s charm lies in its tongue-in-cheek approach, blending action with humor and pop culture references. Each episode offers a new, outlandish threat, from alien invasions to mad scientists.

Though short-lived, its witty narrative and charismatic characters left a lasting impression. Fans still celebrate its unique style and vibrant storytelling, hoping for another chapter in the Middleman’s adventures.

11. Surface (2005–2006)

In “Surface,” the world’s oceans become a stage for mystery and adventure as strange sea creatures begin to appear. The story unfolds through the eyes of scientists and ordinary individuals drawn into the aquatic enigma.

The show captures the awe and terror of the unknown, blending scientific curiosity with human drama. Each episode reveals more about these creatures, hinting at their origins and purpose.

Despite its early conclusion, its blend of intrigue and exploration continues to captivate those who yearn for more. A reboot could dive deeper into the mysteries lurking beneath the ocean’s surface.

12. Kyle XY (2006–2009)

“Kyle XY” introduces viewers to an enigmatic boy found wandering without any memory or a navel. Taken in by the Trager family, Kyle’s extraordinary abilities and mysterious origins become central to the unfolding drama.

The show delves into themes of identity, belonging, and the quest for truth, as Kyle navigates the complexities of human emotion and relationships. Each episode peels back layers of his past, revealing secrets that intrigue and surprise.

Though it left fans with unanswered questions, its impact endures. Many still hope for a continuation of Kyle’s journey, eager to explore the mysteries surrounding his existence.

13. Moonlight (2007–2008)

“Moonlight” blends romance and mystery through the eyes of Mick St. John, a vampire private investigator. Navigating the shadows of Los Angeles, Mick tackles cases involving both humans and supernatural beings.

His struggle with immortality is intertwined with a complicated love story, adding depth to the show’s narrative. Each case he solves provides insight into his eternal conflict, balancing humanity with his vampiric nature.

Though its life on screen was brief, its allure remains strong. Fans still yearn for Mick’s return, eager to unravel more of his timeless adventures in the world of the unknown.